BiPSA Response Form * Return to PeakOilWhen Home

Background: In order to fairly integrate the various PeakOilWhen opinions, we need the community of stakeholders (practically every co-resident of this planet) to express their opinion as to the credentials of the voters. This is your opportunity to do so. The BiPSA operator will use the integrated opinions about the rating of the various credentials in integrating the actual PeakOilWhen votes. By voting here you insure the fairness and credibility of the integrated result. This BiPSA operation is designed to deny its operator any impact on the outcome. Only the community of experts and the community of stakeholders have a say.

You may use it as many times as you please. Each time you will state your opinion with respect to any two factors of relevance: should they have the same or different impact. The opinions of all who fill up this form will count as equal. For more details consult BiPSA: From Controversy to Consensus

Express Your Opinions:

Alice and Bob hold opposite views on the question of PeakOilWhen.

What You Know, or Whom You Serve?
Alice is strongly affiliated with an organization with expressed Peak Oil interests, and Bob is a scholar in a Peak-Oil relevant discipline. Otherwise Alice and Bob are equal.

How would you regard their relative credibility?

Area of Expertise:
Alice is an expert in
Bob is an expert in:
Should Alice's opinion count more than Bob's opinion?

  • No. Alice and Bob should count the same!
  • Yes, marginally.
  • Yes, substantially.
  • Yes, overwhelmingly.
    •

    Affiliation:
    Alice is affiliated with
    Bob is affiliated with:
    Should Alice's opinion count more than Bob's opinion?

  • No. Alice and Bob should count the same!
  • Yes, marginally.
  • Yes, substantially.
  • Yes, overwhelmingly.
    •

    Assuming that in every other respect Alice and Bob are equal

    comments:
    Identification: Please identify yourself and leave your contact information,

    Select: First Name: Last Name:
    eMail:
    Contact Information: ...

    --------

    © The BiPSA Company