Background:
The Controversy:
The energy crisis is on everybody's mind these days. "Oil is
running out" warn the experts, some displaying a Biblical rage,
"...And we should be ready with some alternatives -- or else!"
"...And whatever we choose, we better be kind to our shared, ever
precarious,
environment before Global Warming seals our fate." Many respond
and propose urgent
and massive investments in new ways to quench the increasing thirst for
energy on our record populated planet. Others are advocating drastic
conservation. Albeit the opposite argument is vocal too: "No need
to panic,
drastic conservation is an overkill, oil is plentiful, the Peak is way
out there, and anyway, the marketplace will
ease in the best oil-replacement in due time, using the private sector,
acting
through the wonders of capitalism. The 'peak-stick' is a means by
'socialists' to wrestle control from business to government."
We Cannot Afford to Pick the Wrong Prediction.
If the Peak arrives strategically earlier than policy-expected, global
instability, collapse of the weakest, will likely be our lot. If we are
driven to
'whatever the consequences' action by unfounded fear of an imminent oil
shortage, we will likely damage the environment with dirty energy, and
siphon away resources from promising long-range solutions.
The Science:
From a sceintific point of view the accurate fulfillment of Hubbert's US
Peak-Oil Prediction, validates the logic that predicts the global peak.
The question of "When?" is not settled though. It is by all
accounts a complicated issue to resolve because the answer relies on a
host of knowledge disciplines, requiring more than a single bright
expert in one or two of those knowledge areas. The Peak depends on what
there is down there, how easy or how costly is to pump out. It depends
on the forecast for the cost and availability of alterntive sources.
It is a question of the economic growth of mainly China and India, and
it is impacted by environmentally driven behaviroal changes in the
West. Neither one
of these factors can be computed with comfortable certainty, and hence
no one can scientifically proclaim an immutable precise date.
The Politics:
Politicians talk the talk these days, but when it comes to walking the
walk, they tend to hide behind the raging debate, and claim that the
issue is not settled yet, and no sooner would the scientists agree on a
date, than the powers that be will rise to meet that challenge. Well,
if this PeakOilWhen Initiative successfully rounds up most of
the
experts on all sides of the issue, then the outcome will reflect, for
better or for worse, what we as a society, as repsresented by our
experts,
think of this critical issue. And hence the global peak will be
handled by global opinion, producing the most credible estimate,
the estimate that kills any valid excuse for inaction.
The PeakOilWhen Initiative
Purpose:
To develop a Global Best Estimate for the timing of Global Peak Oil
in order to leverage the powers that be into a decisive remedial
action.
Method:
An aggressive outreach to oil-thoughtful people everywhere, extracting
their wisdom in an integrable way, integrating those opinions through a
scientific, results-neutral methodology; completely transparent,
totaly exposed to critique and indepedent evaluation.
Tool:
BiPSA: Binary Polling Scenrio Analysis. A scientifically sanctioned
procedure developed by Dr. Gideon Samid, head of the Innovation
Appraisal Group at The Department of Chemical Engineering at Case
Western Reserve University. Please read:
[BiPSA: From Controversy to Consensus]
Read more.
Leadership and Execution
The PeakOilWhen initiative is commissioned by the School of
Engineering at Case Western Reserve University, under the leadership of
its Dean, Professor Norman Tien. The School is preparing a
comprehensive energy initiative with PeakOilWhen at its core.
The work is carried out by The BiPSA Co. at Rockville, Maryland which
holds the rights to the
tool and the methodology, granting licenses for various applications.
Vision
The unified PeakOilWhen statement, faithfully integrating the
voice of every oil thoughtful person who cared enough to contribute his
opinion will reflect the wisdom of human society as a whole, giving
measured
credence to its most thoughtful experts. This global peak oil opinion
will by the way it was formed offer a plain challenge to corporate and
government leaders everwhere: "You have before you the best current
estimate for Peak Oil, what are you going to do about it?". We
envision
that the gravity of the danger, and the accumulated credibility of the
estimate will start the ball rolling: more plans and more programs will
be proposed, debated, and eventually acted-upon. The oil and energy
community will request an update for this PeakOilWhen estimate,
and as things begin to happen, this Case Western PeakOilWhen
appraisal will become an anticipated fixture in the global effort to
keep the planet energy rich.
Contact
The School of Engineering at Case Western Reserve University
10900 Euclid Avenue
Cleveland, Ohio 44106
Phone: 216.368.4436
Points of Contact:
Dr. Iwan Alexander
Head, Case Energy Initiative
Dr. Gideon Samid
Head, Case Innovation Appraisal Group
Phone: 571.214.9814
The BiPSA Co.
13 Tapiola Ct.
Rockville, MD 20850
301.424.7990
binarypower@bipsa.com
Your Thoughtful Opinion Makes a Difference.
Vote!